[Issue #048] Give Me a Reason to Care

Have you ever gotten an email from someone who wants to sell you something, and it starts by telling you how great they are?
I received one today, and it hit a nerve.
Instead of just swiping left and deleting it like I usually do, I almost hit reply to explain how bad their email was and why it was bad marketing.
A bit of outrage masked as “I just want to be helpful.”
It started with this:
“Why listen to me: I'm (fill in Name), founder of ABC. This year I was named one of the Top 2 Clay builders in the US, and I taught AI agents at Clay's Sculpt conference.”
That’s his intro.
I don’t know him. I don’t know his company. And I don’t know why that recognition should matter to anything in my company or my life.
His email goes on to become one big, huge, ugly Brag Fest!
Now, those credentials might mean something. They might even be relevant to a problem I have. But he hasn’t made that connection.
He’s giving me reasons to believe him before he’s given me a reason to care.
And that’s a problem.
Somewhere in that crowd is your message
Over the years, I’ve heard all kinds of advice about reaching people with marketing.
Stop the scroll.
Make them curious.
Get their attention.
Make sure they hear everything we think is important.
But we’re on the receiving end of all that advice, too. And most of us are busy trying to get through the day, solve our problems, and take care of the people and responsibilities that matter to us.
Some estimates put our daily exposure to marketing at around 5,000 impressions when you count everything from logos to advertising messages.
Now, you don’t consciously notice all of those. Most pass by without registering. But use some basic deduction, and the picture looks something like this:
5,000 marketing impressions competing for your attention.
Maybe 100 that you consciously notice.
Perhaps a dozen that leave a lasting impression.
Those are ballpark numbers, but they illustrate what your marketing is up against.
And somewhere in that crowd is your message.
So how do you give it a chance?
Start with the story your customer already cares about: their own.
I need more shampoo because we’re out.
I need gas because the light is on.
I need marketing because I need more customers.
I need a counselor because my marriage is in trouble.
I need a vacation because I’m overworked and exhausted.
Some needs are ordinary. Some are deeply personal. But each gives us a reason to pay attention.
If you can help solve a problem that matters to me, you have a chance of getting through.
Three elements that help people care
We teach our clients to recognize good marketing so they have a better understanding of what we are doing and the “Why” behind it. So I’m going to teach you some of those exact things.
Because, when it comes to running your business and how you talk about your company I want you to be equipped to make decisions better than most companies out there.
Whether someone else creates your marketing or you do it yourself, you should be able to recognize the basic structure of a strong message.
WARNING: This will not make you a marketing expert overnight. But it can save you a lot of wasted time and money.
Here are three elements to remember, in this order:
Overt Benefit.
Reason to Believe.
Significant Difference.
Let’s walk through them.
1. Overt Benefit
What’s the main benefit you’re offering? What promise are you making? What problem are you helping someone solve?
Let’s use shampoo as an example.
Does your hair turn into a frizzy mess on a regular basis? Would you like it to look smooth and healthy?
If frizzy hair frustrates you, that’s a benefit you might care about.
But the word overt matters just as much as the word benefit.
You need to make the benefit clear, simple, and obvious. People should quickly understand what’s in it for them so they can decide whether it’s relevant.
This is where a lot of marketing goes wrong. We try to be tricky. We try to be cute. We come up with something clever that makes perfect sense to us because we already know what we mean.
The customer doesn’t have that advantage.
You don’t need to make people solve a puzzle to figure out how you can help them.
Speak clearly and directly to a problem they recognize. If they have that problem and want it solved, you’ve given them a reason to keep listening.
In essence, they’re asking: “Can you help me get the result I want?”
Start by answering that question.
2. Reason to Believe
Once you’ve made a promise, you need to give people a reason to believe you can fulfill it.
How will your shampoo help my hair go from frizzy and out of control to smooth and manageable?
This is where you explain your product or service and offer relevant evidence.
Maybe you can explain how it works in language I understand. Maybe you can show results from people with hair like mine. Maybe you have a demonstration that lets me see the difference.
Several years ago, my daughter started selling hair-care products. For about two years, I got quite an education in frizzy hair, healthy hair, and what people were doing to take care of it.
I also watched her help one person after another. I saw before-and-after results, heard their experiences, and used the products myself.
That gave me reasons to believe.
The connection between the promise and the evidence was clear.
And that’s the point: your evidence needs to support the promise you made.
An award, a credential, or twenty years of experience can help. But you still need to connect it to the result your customer wants.
The email I received skipped the first step. He started giving me reasons to believe without establishing what he was promising to do for me.
Top two at what? Teaching whom? How does that help me?
He left me to figure it out.
Your customer shouldn’t have to work that hard to understand why your qualifications matter.
3. Significant Difference
Now comes the next question:
“Why should I choose you?”
Other companies may promise the same benefit. Some may offer convincing evidence that they can deliver it.
What makes your offer meaningfully different?
The word significant matters here. A difference needs to matter to the customer.
For our hypothetical shampoo company, suppose the customer has already spent a small fortune on products that didn’t work. They’re tired of buying another whole bottle just to discover they’ve made another mistake.
Perhaps your company offers a small trial kit, personal help choosing the right formula, and a money-back guarantee.
For that customer, the chance to try it with less expense and less uncertainty could be a significant difference.
For another customer, something else might matter more.
The question is whether your difference gives the person you’re trying to reach a meaningful reason to choose you.
Keep the explanation straightforward. Once someone is interested, you’ll have opportunities to elaborate.
First, help them see why your offer deserves consideration.
Start noticing
There you have it:
What can you do for me?
Why should I believe you?
Why should I choose you?
Overt Benefit.
Reason to Believe.
Significant Difference.
That’s a useful structure for introducing your offer to someone who doesn’t yet know why they should care.
And as a small-business leader, you need to recognize it. Marketing is one of the areas you’re responsible for, even when someone else does the work.
So here’s something you can do today to improve your marketing and communication skills.
Become an active observer of the marketing around you.
The next time you receive a sales email, see an ad, or visit a company’s website, look for those three elements.
Can you identify the benefit?
Does the evidence give you a reason to believe the promise?
Is there a meaningful reason to choose this company?
Notice where you have to work to figure it out. Notice where you lose interest. Notice what makes you want to know more.
And don’t assume a message works well just because it belongs to a famous brand or shows up everywhere. A big advertising budget doesn’t automatically make a message clear.
Then take a look at your own marketing.
Are you helping people quickly see how you can solve a problem they care about? Have you given them relevant reasons to believe you? Can they see why they should choose you?
Or have you opened with a Brag Fest and left them to figure out the rest?

